Read About Their Fees
You will receive your 2012 CMPA membership fee invoice in the
next few weeks. For most Ontario members, the invoice will be substantially lower
than that of previous years. This is due to a substantial one-time fee credit that
will reduce the 2012 Ontario fee.
Membership fees are calculated based on medico-legal risk in
three fee regions: Ontario, Québec and Rest of Canada. Each region is self-supporting and
there is no subsidization between regions. While the Ontario region’s total fees will
decrease significantly, Québec will experience a small decrease and the Rest of Canada a small
The payment of medical liability protection costs in Ontario is
guided by two agreements.
Firstly and as is the case in other provinces, Ontario
physicians benefit from a program that reimburses them for a portion of their CMPA membership fees.
This long-standing arrangement was negotiated by the Ontario Medical Association (OMA)
and the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care and it is in lieu of other forms of
compensation for clinical work. The reimbursement program contributes to a stable and
sustainable medico-liability system that meets the needs of physicians and their patients.
The second agreement is a Memorandum of Understanding between
the CMPA, the OMA and the Ministry, which guides how, if the CMPA’s assets exceed
forecasted liabilities, fee credits are applied to reduce the monies collected in a given
As a result of the current strong standing of CMPA’s financial
position in Ontario, the total 2012 CMPA fee requirement of $164 million has been reduced by
fee credits of approximately $128 million. As a result, the Association will
collect $36 million from its members or about 25% of the expected cost of medico-legal
protection in the province.
For members, the substantial reduction in total CMPA fees
translates into individual fees for 2012 that are at, or below, 1986 levels. As the reimbursement
program is based on a 1986 threshold, the program will be suspended for 2012 while members
“out-of-pocket” costs will remain consistent with previous years.
Despite the substantial reduction in fee revenue, the CMPA’s
Ontario region remains fully funded.
However, collecting only 25% of the total costs is not a
sustainable approach and CMPA membership fees are expected to return to more normal levels in 2013. The CMPA expects the reimbursement program will also resume in 2013.
Read about the fee setting process.
Tel / Tél : 613-725-2000, 1-800-267-6522
IMPORTANT NOTICE FOR ONTARIO MEMBERS
2012 MEMBERSHIP FEES
n Substantial fee reduction in Ontario
Reimbursement program suspended
Fees expected to return to normal
levels in 2013
QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS
ABOUT THE 2012 CMPA FEE SETTING PROCESS
What are CMPA membership fees?
As a mutual defence organization, the CMPA levies membership fees from physicians wishing to receive medico-legal assistance and protection. This protection consists of medico-legal advice and legal defence on matters related to a physician’s medical professional work. Assistance is determined on a case-by-case basis, and tailored to meet the needs of physicians and their specific circumstances.
How are CMPA fees established?
In setting membership fees, the CMPA estimates the future cost of medical liability protection for the care provided in that year. These actuarial calculations are done on a regional basis to ensure that each of the three fee setting regions is responsible for its own costs. In addition to differentiating fees by region, the calculations are also based on the type of work (family medicine, surgical specialty, trainee, etc.). This ensures that the fee structure reflects the risks inherent in each member’s type of medical practice as well as regional differences in medico-legal costs.
What are fee setting regions and how do they differ?
The CMPA has established three fee regions:
Ontario, Québec and Rest of Canada. The Rest of Canada region includes the western and Atlantic provinces as well as the three territories.
What are fee credits?
In establishing membership fees, the CMPA’s goal is to hold one dollar of assets for each discounted dollar of anticipated liability, including expected awards, settlements, legal and administrative expenses. When the assets exceed the actuarial estimate of current and future liabilities, the CMPA may allocate funds as fee credits. Conversely, when the estimated costs exceed assets, the aggregate fees are gradually increased to maintain the Association’s fully funded status.
What is the reimbursement program?
The medical associations or federations in each province and territory have negotiated, with their respective provincial or territorial governments, arrangements that see physicians reimbursed some or all of their membership fees. These long-standing arrangements were negotiated by the medical associations or federations in lieu of other forms of compensation for clinical work. This arrangement has contributed to a stable practice environment for Canadian physicians.
What are the 2012 total fee requirements per region?
total 2012 fee requirement of $79 million has been reduced by over $9 million in fee credits. The CMPA will therefore collect $70 million from Québec members, an amount which is slightly less than in 2011.
total 2012 fee requirement of $164 million has been reduced by fee credits of approximately $128 million. As a result, the CMPA will collect $36 million from Ontario members, an amount which is substantially less than 2011.
Rest of Canada:
the total 2012 fee requirement of
$128 million has been reduced by over $37 million in free credits. The CMPA will collect approximately $90 million from members in the Rest of Canada region, an amount which is slightly higher than in 2011.
Why are circumstances different in Ontario?
While the overall approach to CMPA assistance and protection is consistent across the country, the membership fee model is designed to reflect the differences in medical liability costs in each region.
The positive funding position in Ontario has enabled the application of a substantial fee credit for 2012. For members in that fee paying region, the Ministry OMA negotiated reimbursement program will be suspended in 2012. Are other regions affected by the Ontario allocation of large fee credits?
The allocation of fee credits in Ontario does not impact the other fee regions, as each region is self-supporting.